Yet, fischer is not convinced that abortion is sufficiently justified on grounds that sustaining the fetus is an inconvenience. Does judith jarvis thomson really grant the prolife view. For the sake of the argument a human embryo is a person. However, throughout the article she underlines key arguments and give multiple examples and analogies to further prove her point. If its a person, then it is usually thought that the argument against abortion is sound, much as we saw with noonan. Judith jarvis thomson, in a defense of abortion, argues that even if we grant that fetuses have a fundamental right to life, in many cases the rights of the mother override the rights of a fetus. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson essay. This is part 2 part 1 is here of a specially written essay by dagmar wilhelm who lectures in philosophy at keele university. A defense of abortion most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion hcc learning web. A former assistant pastor of the lutheran church of the messiah in princeton, n. A defense of abortion critical exposition the goal of judith jarvis thomson in her defense of abortion is to sway the ideas of those who are against abortion by challenging the arguments they give for thinking so.
Thomson argues that even if one grants to the prolifer her most important. Judith jarvis thomson argues in a defense of abortion that the right to life is not a right to another persons body. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and public. Defense on abortion defense on abortion on page 4050. Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the. Summary of judith jarvis thomsons, a defense of abortion. Thomsons a defense of abortion a common argument against abortion. Thomson grants for the sake of argument the premise that a human embryo is a person she challenges the idea that one can argue effectively from this premise to the conclusion that all abortion is morally impermissible.
T does not think the conceptus a neutral way of referring to the fetus is a person from the moment of conception, anymore than an acorn is an oak tree. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every human fetus has a right to life, he shows that each of these arguments fails on its own terms. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson in the article a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person. As directly killing an innocent person is murder, and murder is always and absolutely impermissible, an abortion may not be performed.
The premise is argued for, but, as i think, not well. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and thank you very much for reading a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and. In this paper i will give a fairly detailed description of thomson main arguments for abortion. A defense of abortion by judith thomson 0 words cram. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson 1971. In an in teresting and widely read article, judith jarvis thomson has. In a defense of abortion, she demonstrates that even if a fetus is a person, it may still be aborted. Judith jarvis thomsons defense of abortion gilbert meilaender, ph. Judith thomson, in a defense of abortion, argues her thoughts towards abortion, by using forms of analogies and acknowledges the right to life a fetus has, but also argues that the unborn babys right to life does not over ride the pregnant womens right to make choices and have control over her body.
Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. A defense of abortion 1971 judith jarvis thomson do you agree that opposition to abortion relies on premise that fetus is a human being, a person, from moment of conception. Studydiscussion questions 1971 judith jarvis thomson. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson 1287.
A defense of abortion by david boonin cambridge core. An analysis of judith jarvis thomsons a defense of abortion. A defense of abortion judith thomson article simply outlines the right of abortion with women. Debates over abortion are ordinarily thought to hinge on the status of the fetus. Judith jarvis thomson most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. It is rare that one will find near universal agreement as to the most important paper written on a particular subject, but that is exactly what we find with judith jarvis thomsons 1971 paper, a defense of abortion, whose impact on the discussion on the morality of abortion cannot be overstated.
On the responsibility objection to thomsons argument. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library. Judith shows the extreme view is false because 14 is false. One more look at judith thomsons a defense of abortion. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Philosophers and the issue of abortion page 1 of 6 72700 philosophers and the issue of abortion published in essays in the philosophy of humanism, m. Start studying judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson 1971 most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human. The argument proceeds on the supposition that a fetus has a right to life and is a person. Pdf this is an analysis of the argument presented by thomson on the premise that a woman has absolute rights to decide on abortion. Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion to print or download this file, click the link below. The step from a fetus is a person to abortion is morally wrong is usually taken for granted.
Judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion philpapers. On judith jarvis thomsons a defence of abortion dagmar wilhelm. But as directly killing an innocent person is always and absolutely impermissible, and abortion may not be performed. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and public affairs,vol. Thomsons thought experiments have met with a lot of criticism. Judith thompson and the case for abortion sophia project. Granting for the sake of argument that the fetus has a right to life, thomson uses thought experiments to argue that the fetuss right to life does not trump the pregnant womans right to have jurisdiction over her body, and that induced abortion is therefore not. Whoever has a right to life should never be killed. Judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion flashcards. In israel, for example, abortion is allowed only if there is an application to and approval by a pregnancy termination committee, and as of 1993, legal access to abortion had been narrowed through stricter limitations on the discretion of those committees to approve abortion. David boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Does judith jarvis thomson really grant the prolife view of fetal. In her groundbreaking 1971 article, a defense of abortion, judith jarvis.
Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Russo i n the united states, the abortion debate has typically been framed in terms of rights, usually pitting the fetus right to life against the mothers right to control her body. As you may know, people have look numerous times for their favorite novels like this a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and, but end up in infectious downloads. In this article, thomson uses the phrase permissible to mean within ones moral rights. A defense against abortion by judith jarvis 1439 words. Meilaender is on the faculty of the department of religion at oberlin college in ohio. Here is a table that illustrates the parallel features. Thomsons t imaginative examples and controversial conclusions have made a defense of abortion perhaps the most widely reprinted essay in all of contemporary philosophy. In her groundbreaking 1971 article, a defense of abortion, judith jarvis thomson argues that even if one grants to the prolifer her most important premisethat the fetus is a personthe prolifers conclusion, the intrinsic wrongness of abortion, does not follow. For the sake of argument, thomson grants the initial contention that the fetus has a right to. Judith thomsons defense of abortion flashcards quizlet. Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment.
So when thomson argues that it is permissible for a woman to abort a. Judith presents the argument that everyone has a right to life. Thomson defends the case by the premise that life begins at the moment of. Moral philosophers who are pro or antichoice alike have argued about the argumentative strategy that is best to support ones claims concerning abortion. We are asked to notice that the development of a human being from conception through birth into childhood is continuous. There are three objections to this, every person has the right to life, which means even though a mother has the right to decide what goes in and out of her body, and as soon as the fetus. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson page 1 judith jarvis thomson. In this video, professor thorsby discusses judith jarvis thomsons essay a defense of abortion. Judith thompson and the case for abortion michael s.
Therefore, on her view, fetal personhood does not entail the impermissibility of abortion. Thomson began by saying that because everyone has a right to life, it is automatically. Judith jarvis thomsons defence on abortion essay 2254 words. Start studying judith thomsons defense of abortion. As we shall see, judith thomson vir tually admits as much in her a defense of abortion. Conservatives argue that the fetus is a person from the moment of conception, and, therefore, should enjoy.
316 913 1325 266 1403 631 1315 1614 1358 27 681 1630 135 304 1224 95 479 1304 57 1033 236 861 937 546 844 166 802 1329 276 1533 757 1414 873 1395 72 1479 150 620 661